The magnitude of one game doesn’t completely define an NFL draft evaluation. However, the grades are weighted based on level of competition and how an individual performs in the biggest moments.
Case in point, this week’s trending lists lean heavily into last weekend’s matchup between the Alabama Crimson Tide and Georgia Bulldogs. Both programs are always littered with future NFL talent, and playing each other is the best overall glimpse toward the next level.
Inevitably, a contest of that caliber will be used as a linchpin regarding specific evaluations, starting with quarterbacks Jalen Milroe and Carson Beck. One looked great. The other didn’t.
The Bleacher Report Scouting Department of Brandon Thorn, Cory Giddings, Dame Parson and Matt Holder will discuss multiple prospects from that game who either impressed or disappointed.
Ramifications can also be felt in this week’s top 10 mock draft—order determined by this week’s Power Rankings—where two quarterbacks find themselves in the top 10. But Beck isn’t one of them.
Alabama’s Jalen Milroe has been exceptional this season. He opened the campaign with eight passing and six rushing touchdowns through the first three games. He upped the ante Saturday against the Georgia Bulldogs. Milroe threw for 374 yards, ran for 117 more and accounted for five scores.
“Milroe proved against Georgia’s defense last Saturday night that he is a game changer from the quarterback position,” Parson said. “Milroe was highly effective and efficient as a passer in this game, but his rushing ability proved too much for the Bulldogs defense to handle. This was the first time anyone made those athletes look slow on tape. He has access to every blade of grass due to his dual-threat abilities.
“Milroe is creeping forward steadily into first-round territory with his early-season performance.”
2. OT Josh Simmons, Ohio State
The 2024 offensive tackle class is looking a little rough to start the cycle. But Ohio State left tackle Josh Simmons is quickly establishing himself as a potential NFL blindside protector.
“It is important to begin any analysis of Simmons with the fact that Ohio State has played a cupcake schedule so far with just one of their four games being against a Big Ten opponent (Michigan State) and that being the lowest margin of victory at 31 points,” Thorn said. “Even so, Simmons’ wide-bodied frame, quick feet, balance and finishing skills have been eye-catching.
“With shades of what Christian Darrisaw looked and moved like at Virginia Tech a few years ago, Simmons is fluid in pass protection with the range to beat widely aligned rushers to the spot while remaining under control through contact and the top of the drop, a telltale sign of a pro tackle. He also brings an edge as a finisher with the physical, aggressive mindset to set the tone for a line.
“As Ohio State gets further into conference play, the foundation is in place to put him into OT1 consideration.”
3. WR Tre Harris, Ole Miss
The Ole Miss Rebels offense makes it difficult to evaluate prospects, because very little of what the team does translates to the NFL. However, some talents supersede the system. Wide receiver Tre Harris looks the part.
“Harris did not step back in his first action against SEC competition last weekend. He kept his foot on the pedal and made play after play for Ole Miss’ offense,” Parson said. “His quarterback, Jaxson Dart, threw for 261 yards against Kentucky. Harris accounted for 11 receptions, 177 yards receiving and the only receiving touchdown.
“Ole Miss’ WR1 did a nice job with route tempo to keep defensive backs on their toes. Harris was heavily involved in the quick passing game, where his size and strength could shine. He proved to the Rebels’ offensive MVP in the game.”
Leave a Reply