Among the Cardinals’ potential trade candidates, Helsley stands out as a prime target for the Yankees. Known for his blazing fastball and exceptional closing abilities, Helsley could provide the Yankees with a formidable bullpen boost. With one year of control left before free agency, Helsley’s availability presents an attractive option for the Yankees, who are looking to add elite pitching depth to support their 2025 campaign.

CBS Sports’ Mike Axisa recently mentioned the Yankees among top contenders for Helsley, speculating that the Yankees, alongside teams like the Houston Astros, Los Angeles Dodgers, and Philadelphia Phillies, could leverage their resources to secure his services. These high-profile clubs are motivated to acquire a seasoned closer, and Helsley’s proven track record makes him particularly valuable for teams aiming for a postseason run.

Helsley’s 2024 season highlights his appeal: he posted a 7-4 record with a 2.04 ERA, 49 saves, and limited batters to a .210 average across 66 1/3 innings. With 79 strikeouts against 23 walks and a 1.10 WHIP, he has consistently showcased his reliability in high-pressure situations. According to Spotrac, Helsley’s market value is estimated around $80 million for a six-year deal, roughly $13 million annually. Entering his final year of arbitration, Helsley’s salary is set for a significant increase from the $3.8 million he earned in 2024.

Yankees’ prospect depth makes deal possible

For the Yankees, acquiring Helsley aligns with their championship aspirations. Their robust prospect pool could make a trade feasible, as the Yankees have the necessary assets to meet the Cardinals’ demands. Meanwhile, the Cardinals, with a farm system currently ranked 19th, would benefit from young talent in exchange, allowing them to solidify their roster for a future return to competitiveness.

By targeting Helsley, the Yankees could fill a crucial role, gaining an elite closer to support their bullpen. The Dodgers also remain a strong suitor, but the Yankees’ prospect depth and financial capability make them a frontrunner for Helsley’s services.

The Cardinals’ willingness to trade Helsley reflects their commitment to a youth-driven rebuild. Trading Helsley for a high return from a team like the Yankees offers St. Louis a way to replenish their farm system, aligning with their goal of developing a sustainable, winning franchise. For Yankees fans, a potential Helsley trade represents an opportunity to strengthen their roster and aim for a deep playoff run, as the addition of an elite reliever could be a critical factor for success.

With the Yankees likely to pursue bullpen reinforcements this offseason, Helsley’s availability may set the stage for a blockbuster move, one that would benefit both franchises in their respective pursuits of a successful 2025 season and beyond.